4 Comments
User's avatar
Victor Maengahama's avatar

The movement from a profit position in the PY to such a material loss position in CY just doesn’t make sense to me. Sure the margins dropped slightly and costs were up 11.9%. All the performance indicators are comparable except that PY trading profit. Smells like a prior period error. Unless there was a material unusual event in the PY?

Expand full comment
Tinashe Mukogo's avatar

Good point. So they also had some big one time cost such as impairments and some restructuring costs.

The management team was newish so I guess they did a review of the business and wanted to take all the hits up front and so relooked at impairments and credit losses more aggressively.

These factors plus operational decline all played a part.

Expand full comment
Marvin's avatar

I would buy the shares if they can find experienced restructuring executives.

Expand full comment
Marvin's avatar

Actually it looks like the restructuring is underway.

Expand full comment